How To Make Grilled Cheese In Toaster Oven

How To Make Grilled Cheese In Toaster Oven

Learn the secret to making mouth-watering grilled cheese in your toaster oven – it’s easier than you think!

To make the perfect grilled cheese in your toaster oven, start by preheating it to 375°F. Then, assemble your sandwich with bread and cheese, adding any desired toppings. Place the sandwich on a foil-lined tray and bake for 10-12 minutes until golden brown and crispy.

In my experience, making grilled cheese in a toaster oven is quick and easy. It’s a great option for a tasty snack or meal when you’re short on time. Plus, since the heat comes from both the top and bottom of the toaster oven, the bread gets nice and crispy while the cheese melts perfectly. Give it a try!  I highly recommend it!

In this article, we will discuss the step-by-step process of making grilled cheese in a toaster oven, along with some helpful tips to ensure your sandwich turns out perfectly.

So let us Dive in,

Material You Need

Before we start, make sure you have the following materials on hand:

  1. Toaster Oven
  2. Bread
  3. Cheese (any type you prefer – cheddar, American, Swiss, etc.)
  4. Foil-lined tray or baking sheet
  5. Toppings (optional)

Preparation Steps for Toaster Oven Grilled Cheese

There are a few essential steps you need to follow when making grilled cheese in a toaster oven. Let’s go through them together:

Step 1: Preheat your toaster oven

Preheating the toaster oven is crucial for achieving that perfect golden brown, crispy exterior. Set the temperature to 375°F and let it preheat while you prepare the sandwich.

Step 2: Assemble your sandwich

Take two slices of bread and place a layer of cheese on one slice. Add any desired toppings, such as sliced tomatoes, ham, bacon, etc. Top it off with another slice of cheese and place the second bread slice on top.

Step 3: Place the sandwich on a foil-lined tray

Using a foil-lined tray or baking sheet will help prevent any melted cheese from dripping onto your toaster oven. It also makes for an easier cleanup!

Step 4: Bake for  10-12 minutes

Place the sandwich in the toaster oven and bake for 10-12 minutes, or until the bread is golden brown and the cheese is melted.

Step 5: Let cool before slicing

Once your grilled cheese is done, remove it from the toaster oven and let it cool for a minute or two. This will prevent burned fingers when slicing into the hot sandwich.

Step 6: Enjoy your delicious grilled cheese!

Carefully slice the sandwich in half and enjoy your perfectly melted, crispy grilled cheese. You can also pair it with a bowl of tomato soup for a classic and satisfying meal.

Best Cheese Types for Toaster Oven Grilled Cheese

While you can use any type of cheese for your toaster oven grilled cheese, some types work better than others.

Here are a few recommendations to take your sandwich to the next level:


Cheddar cheese is a classic choice for grilled cheese due to its sharp and tangy flavor. It also melts well, making it perfect for toaster oven grilled cheese.


American cheese may not be the most gourmet option, but it’s a crowd-pleaser for sure. Its creamy texture when melted makes it an excellent choice for toaster oven grilled cheese.


If you want to add a bit of sophistication to your grilled cheese, try using Swiss cheese. Its nutty and buttery flavor pairs well with a variety of toppings.

There are plenty of other delicious cheese options available, so feel free to get creative and experiment with different combinations!

5 Different Methods To Make Grilled Cheese In Toaster Oven

Aside from the traditional method of baking the grilled cheese in a toaster oven, there are a few other ways you can make this tasty snack:

Broiling Method

Instead of baking the sandwich, you can also broil it by placing it on a foil-lined tray and setting your toaster oven to broil mode. Keep an eye on the sandwich as it will cook faster using this method.

Sandwich Maker Method

If you have a sandwich maker or panini press, you can also use it to make grilled cheese. Simply assemble the sandwich as usual and place it in the machine for a few minutes until golden brown and crispy.

Air Fryer Method

Believe it or not, you can also make grilled cheese in an air fryer! Place the sandwich in the air fryer basket and cook for 8-10 minutes at 375°F. This method results in a crispy exterior while keeping the inside of the sandwich nice and gooey.

Microwave Method

While using a microwave won’t result in a crispy exterior, it’s a quick and easy option for making grilled cheese. Simply assemble the sandwich on a microwave-safe plate and cook for 30 seconds to 1 minute, or until the cheese is melted.

Over-the-Stove Method

If you don’t have a toaster oven or other kitchen appliances, you can still make grilled cheese using the stovetop. Add a little butter or oil to a pan and cook the sandwich over medium heat for a few minutes on each side, until golden brown and crispy.

Tips for Making Perfect Toaster Oven Grilled Cheese

To ensure your toaster oven grilled cheese turns out delicious every time, here are a few helpful tips to keep in mind:

Tip 1: Use room temperature cheese and bread

Using cold cheese or bread can result in an unevenly cooked sandwich. Make sure to let your ingredients come to room temperature before assembling the sandwich.

Tip 2: Butter the outside of the bread

To achieve that perfect crispy exterior, make sure to butter the outside of the bread slices before placing them in the toaster oven.

Tip 3: Don’t skimp on cheese

For the best flavor and melted texture, don’t be afraid to use a generous amount of cheese in your sandwich.

Tip 4: Experiment with toppings

While a classic grilled cheese is delicious on its own, adding toppings like sliced tomatoes or avocado can add an extra layer of flavor and nutrition to the sandwich.

Tip 5: Don’t walk away

Toaster ovens can cook quickly, so make sure to keep an eye on your sandwich and check it regularly to prevent burning.

5 Best Bread Types for Toaster Oven Grilled Cheese

The type of bread you use can make a significant difference in the taste and texture of your grilled cheese. Here are some popular options to try:


Sourdough bread has a tangy flavor that pairs well with the richness of melted cheese. Its crust also gets nice and crispy when toasted, adding an extra crunch to your grilled cheese.

Whole Grain

Using whole grain bread will not only add extra nutrition to your sandwich, but its heartier texture can also hold up against the melted cheese without getting soggy.


For a more indulgent option, try using brioche bread for your grilled cheese. Its buttery and fluffy texture takes this simple snack to the next level.


Rye bread adds a unique flavor profile to your grilled cheese and is perfect for those who prefer a heartier and more robust taste.


For those with dietary restrictions, there are also gluten-free bread options available that work well in toaster oven grilled cheese. Just make sure to choose a sturdy type of bread that won’t fall apart when

With these tips and methods, you can make the perfect grilled cheese using your trusty toaster oven.

So next time you’re craving this comforting snack, skip the stovetop and try out one of these convenient and delicious options!

Serving and Pairing Ideas for Toaster Oven Grilled Cheese

To take your toaster oven grilled cheese to the next level, here are a few serving and pairing ideas:

Serve with Soup

As mentioned earlier, grilled cheese and tomato soup make for a classic and satisfying combination. Try making homemade tomato soup or pair your sandwich with other types of soups like butternut squash or broccoli cheddar.

Add Protein

For a heartier meal, add some protein to your grilled cheese sandwich. Options like bacon, ham, or sliced turkey can elevate the flavor and make it more filling.

Pair with a Salad

To balance out the richness of the grilled cheese, serve it alongside a fresh salad. The contrast of textures and flavors will make for a well-rounded and satisfying meal.

Enjoy with Fruit

For a sweet and savory combo, try pairing your grilled cheese with some fresh fruit. Apples, pears, and grapes all make for great options that add a refreshing element to the meal.

Try Different Dips

Instead of ketchup or tomato soup, try dipping your grilled cheese in other sauces like ranch dressing, honey mustard, or even jam for a unique flavor experience.

Cleaning and Maintenance of Your Toaster Oven

To make sure your toaster oven lasts and continues to produce delicious grilled cheese, it’s important to clean and maintain it regularly. Here are a few tips:

Unplug and Let Cool Before Cleaning

Before cleaning your toaster oven, always unplug it from the power source and let it cool down completely.

Wipe Down Crumbs

Regularly wipe down the crumb tray and interior of the toaster oven with a damp cloth to remove any food particles or crumbs.

Clean Removable Parts

If your toaster oven has removable parts, such as the baking rack or drip tray, make sure to wash them in warm soapy water after each use.

Use Oven Cleaner for Tough Stains

For tougher stains on the interior of your toaster oven, use a specialty oven cleaner and follow the instructions carefully.

Replace Foil or Parchment Paper Liners

If you use foil or parchment paper to line your toaster oven for grilling cheese, make sure to replace it after each use to prevent any buildup of grease or food residue.

Toaster Oven Grilled Cheese Safety Precautions

Toaster ovens may seem like a simple and safe appliance, but it’s important to keep these safety precautions in mind when using them for grilling cheese:

Always Supervise

Never leave your toaster oven unattended while it’s in use. It’s essential to keep an eye on the sandwich and check it regularly to prevent any accidents or burning.

Use Oven Mitts

Since toaster ovens can get hot, always use oven mitts or a kitchen towel when handling the sandwich or removing it from the toaster oven.

Keep Away from Water

Toaster ovens should never be used near water sources, and any spills should be cleaned up immediately to avoid electrical hazards.

Allow Space for Air Circulation

Make sure to keep a few inches of space around the toaster oven, especially near the vents, to allow for proper air circulation and prevent overheating.

Follow the Manufacturer’s Instructions

Always refer to the manufacturer’s instructions and safety guidelines when using your specific model of toaster oven. This will ensure safe and proper usage.


Toaster oven grilled cheese is a quick, convenient, and delicious meal option that can be easily customized to your preferences. With the right bread, toppings, and cooking methods, you can enjoy a perfectly golden and melted grilled cheese without ever having to turn on your stove. Just make sure to follow safety precautions and properly maintain your toaster oven for long-lasting use.

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *